Ive made many of your recipes with much success. Baobab oil. Borage oil is a wonderful source of fatty acids, and is the highest natural source of linoleic acid. For example, things like Germall Liquid Plus, according to my limited research is not vegan and I have a hard time finding a vegan preservative. The oils in this category vary wildly in terms of texture, colour, thickness, nutritional composition, and scent, but generally they are our base oils/butters. Honestly, that recipe sounds bad. Even though the grapeseed oil is considered fast absorbing, it felt too greasy-feeling for my liking. And remembertrust yourself! I use coconut oil in the toothpaste I make, but it is always liquid in the summer. So before I found that post I found this one which is helpful on a different issues re: CO replacement. I was wondering about one thing: can I mix ingredients so as to have the properties of both ingredients? Carrier oil substitution list for DIY beauty products! Mango and cupuacu butters would be my top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter . I see coconut oil used in many recipes that help in having a creamy texture since its a soft oil, but its frustrating for me since coconut oil is always liquid in our country. 2-3 Drops Tea Tree Oil I am making a salve for eczema and it calls for neem oil. Ive never worked with shea oil before, but it sounds like you could use it in recipes that call for heavier oils, like avocado oil, in a 1:1 swap. Soap is always going to be basic, and studies have shown repeated and ongoing exposure to high pH cleansers is not good for our acid mantle (https://simpleskincarescience.com/ph-acid-mantle/). So, when youre trading ingredients, your first consideration should be if the replacement ingredient is the same consistency as the original at room temperature. Hello! 11 Emollients, found in ointments and lipid-based tears, typically use a combination of mineral oil, light . Any suggestions? I thank you and I will read the rest of your blog. Shea butter is not a thing Id put in an anti-acne creamthats a bit like asking what you could add to spinach to make a cake. So I have a question for you that you may not be able to answer, but Ill try anyways! But, based on the other posts youve recommended that I read, candelilla has a smoother and not as sticky feeling as beeswax and that its possible to help the salve absorb faster if I were to change some of the olive oil to something like grape seed oil (camellia is a little pricey!). Shea Butter 3% This cellulite cream is loaded with grapefruit, but honestly I couldnt imagine putting it on before exercising. However grape seed isnt the longest lasting oil. Studies have found it to be helpful for treating mild to moderate eczema. Thanks so much for reading & DIYing with me , Recipe requests are welcomed suggestions and inspiration, but thats it. I need to avoid these for a relative with a tree nut allergy. This is Perfect!! However, there is limited research to support its effectiveness . Sorry no it also called for lemongrass cypress and lavender, Honestly, I dont see any of those EOs doing anything meaningful for spider veins, either. Is there something else that can be substituted for this?? Olus oil is an oil of 100% vegetable origin made from a blend of natural triglycerides. I was thinking of replacing 50% shea butter with shea nut oil & boosting the cocoa butter with an equal part or maybe adding wax. This wonderful Guide is just Best thing you can do for anybody whos learning about Essential Oils and trying to live a natural life. Hey Heidi! I am wondering where I can find more information about absorption. Borage oil (BO) is a natural substance that provides high levels GLA, which is a type of polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA). Hi! Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress, You'll need to upload them to a free image hosting service first. Ive recently started making soap and selling it on Etsy, which is really fun. Hope thats ok with you) is whether I could use hot process for your soap recipes? I do not see Neem oil here where would it fall? Im thrilled to hear it, Susan Enjoy all all your new DIY concoctions! What can I add to Shea Butter to make an anti acne face cream? My issue is, do i need a carrier that absorbs quickly or a bit of botha s it needs to absorb over 24 hours (but i dont want to be greasy all day. Baobab oil is rich in fatty acids and vitamins A, D, E, as well as some antioxidants. Hi Jeannie! Im fairly confident Liquid Germall Plus (INCI: Propylene Glycol, Diazolidinyl Urea, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate) is fully synthetic. A recipe for PP that I want to follow calls for the use of Canola Oil. high in linoleic and gamma linolenic acids (also known as vitamin F). Shea butter, up close and personal. What substitute would you recommend? Thanks in advance! Is there a substitute that can be used in stead? The consistency of an individual carrier oil is based on its consistency at room temperature. No. Hello from frigid Hamilton. They grew up together, so they are all my babies. thank you so much! If you liked this article you should also check out my article on essential oil substitutions and my brief guide to solubility , Wow! Hello Ati! Required fields are marked *. Im so glad to have hooked you . As I explain in the article, shea butter and coconut oil arent generally a good swap as they have drastically different melting points and textures. My other suggestion would be to check out the list of advanced search results on psoriasis at NDA. but, i think your other recipes ive looked at have convinced me to try out some cocoa butter next. I began researching all kinds of vitamin-c infused serums, trying to find one that was a decent price but all the while meeting its expectations. Butters - Most butters are interchangeable. But it came out super oily. Hey Cindy! Sometimes the answer is a quick yes, and sometimes its a complicated no. I can get hold of this as bulk powder measure the milligrams then add to a carrier and apply 1ml per day on shoulders chest. Great blog you have! I am working on making some substitutions in a hand repair balm and landed on your page! Whats a great substitute for Aloe vera butter? I have been reading quite a few articles about how Vitamin-C is the must-have ingredient in your skin products. No lotion, just runny milky failure. The most important purpose after being the base of every formulation is consistency. From my experience with lip balm, most of the moisturizing bunch comes from the concentration of beeswax. Hi! Hi Alexa! Thanks for reading and I look forward to your response! Yes, doooooo it! Some sink in quickly, some slowly, and some very, very slowly. Honey is also a humectant, though, so if it can attract enough water to itself there can eventually be enough water that some of it has some free time to go cause trouble. What is a substitute for borage? Hopefully something in there is helpful. Sorry if I overlooked the info, but am hoping you can point me to a resource (chart, website, etc.) Ive never worked with it, I have no intentions of doing so (though it will be legal here in Canada fairly soon), and I really cant tell you anything about working with itsorry. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. And GOD bless you for sharing your knowledge with us. Im 6 months new into using essential oils and now making my own body butters, lip butters, cellulite creams etc.. Thatll be a fairly thin, fast-absorbing lotion regardless of oils used Happy making! Read up on em and see what sounds good , Thanks Marie! Hi KayeI never recommend using palm or palm kernel oil, but from what Ive read palm kernel oil can be used instead of coconut oil with relatively similar results.Babassu oil is another non-palm alternative (though significantly more expensive). I read through the comments and read about someone who doesnt like the coconut oil but my skin actually cant handle it. thanks. I am making salves and am wondering if substituting out some coconut oil for some cocoa butter would either make the salve softer or more solid? If youd like to hire me to ensure you get your formula, get in touch . My first guess is that you didnt use high-shear blending on the second one? A few quick tips to start off with; if youre developing a recipe that youd like to be able to make over and over again with identical results, you should switch to weight, rather than volume. Can I use that instead of coconut oil? As a general rule, if one oil is solid at room temperature and another is liquid, then their melting points are definitely not similar The melting point of the liquid oil is going to be well below room temperature, whereas the one for the solid oil is obvious above it. I was wondering should I put more shea or coconut oil for my lotion? Hopefully you can help me with this! Have you checked out some of my body oil and cleansing oil formulations for ideas? It would not be a good substitution oil. Im hoping not to use wax. Im highly allergic to it (apparently very rare lol) and meadowfoam oil appears to be quite difficult to acquire in Australia unfortunately. I am highly allergic to tree nuts and have been asking about substituting coconut oil and not a one person gave me a good answer.your break down of liquid, soft, and brittle oils was PERFECT! Would you think this oil/butter combination is good? I know that I am coming into the conversation late, but I am very allergic to tree nuts so I dont use their oils. Ive shared many over the years . Hi KD! I just woke up and its -8C here, and its only going to get worse over the coming months . I do make my own soap/shampoo bars, etc. You can definitely use it in lotions; heres a good one! Baobab oil has a percentage of saturated fatty acids which makes it a good oil to use to extend the . If you want to experiment with this sort of thing go ahead, just make sure everything is sealed off from additional moisture, label everything, and keep an eye on it to ensure nothing funky is going on . 5. Thank you. PLEASE CONSIDER!! nerolidol (an essential oil in plants). Then you have a carrot oil (from the plant) that contains oodles of Vitamin A! I thought it might be nice to offer clients over xmas. Two, in facthere and here You should also just peruse my The Basics section, theres lots of good articles in there on things like solubility and stuff not to buy that you might find useful! Can you please help me with the ingredient measurement? Should I use a different oil? What could I use instead? Please help!!!! Good news is that I didnt put any EOs in so that I can just reheat it. Itll save you a lot of money and ingredients as you play. Id toss it in the special characteristics/healing category, along with special consideration for the scent Its also really slow to absorb. P.s. I was thinking babassu oil? what would you say are the differences between shea butter & mango butter besides shea butters smell? Can I add Shea Butter on my sugar, coconut oil, almond oil to make a more creamy scrub? Hi, All that said, because lip gloss is usually primarily thickened with wax and the acceptable range of consistencies of lip gloss is relatively broad, you could probably make this swap without it being too detrimental to the recipebut that has nothing to do with the melting of the coconut oil and everything to do with the broader context of the recipe. Do you think a balm with tumeric butter, St. Johns wort oil and beeswax would work? Photo by Pixaby. Can you give any ideas on how to make it a firm Chapstick consistancy? I really wouldnt recommend using your expensive oils in place of cheap oils here. I want to make an under eye cream using carrot seed oil, green tea extract and as much of good ingredients ive learned from your recipe as possible (allantoin,hydrolyzed silk,Panthenol, Vit E oil, evening primrose oil and even maybe sodium lactate! However, it is so prevalent in most recipes. Been going through a major maskne flare-up, and adding borage oil to my routine (will detail in comments) seems to make my blemishes much less angry. Yes, fatty acid composition is almost the entirety of the differences between the different butters. If you have any other questions/entries youd like to see, feel free to pass the ideas along , Hi Im making this recipe for acne and scars. Ive specifically been trying to find out about jojoba & argan oils. Sounds wonderful, and I have almost everything to make it. And, dont forget to include a preservative, which youll need to do with anything that contains water. I was reading through your post and kind of thought that maybe cocoa butter would be better but I just wanted to double-check. Borage Oil Properties is conditioning and produces a stable lather in soap. This is one of the most beneficial posts I have read about the different oils. that helps convert the carrier oils in recipes, i.e. Namely 7-keto Benefits Borage has been linked to a. First, let me say congrats on your Blog engine updates. 1 beeswax : 2 coconut oil is perfect for 32-34 celcius. The content is not intended to be a substitute for . 6 drops frankincense oil I love the info about the oils, thank you! What was the oil to water ratio in your lotion? really helpful post. This thanksgiving I am having my daughters and three of their come home. My observations on shea butter are similar to yoursits thick and greasy, and definitely in the slow to very slow category when it comes to absorption. Hope this makes sense. But the absobstion speed is sooooo slow. Thank you for this very hepful article. Thank you so much, I am keeping all this information in a notebook and in Evernote ( Online). Borage seed oil is a good substitute only for skin and hair. This is because shea butter is soft and sticky at room temperature, whereas cocoa butter is smooth and brittle, like a bar of dark chocolate. Your body converts it into hormone-like . So, when swapping out oils in a formulation where absorbency is important, ensure the replacement oil is pretty similar to the original in terms of absorption speed. When it comes to beeswax/borax emulsions (aka old fashioned cold creams) they are always going to be much heavier than lotions made with more modern emulsifiers. Is it okay to mix different carrier oils together? Thanks for your post! Thank you Lily for taking the time to respond o my query. Carrier oils serve a variety of purposes. To create gluten-free versions of foods that usually contain gluten is typically a pretty involved process requiring a complete re-formulation from the ground up, taking into account the lack of gluten from the get-go. Hi I really enjoyed your article, very well informed and shows me how much I dont know! INCI: Borago Officinalis Seed Oil: Appearance: Pale yellow liquid oil: Usage rate: Up to 100%: Texture: A thick, heavy oil: Scent Thanks, Sarah! Thanks so much! Id recommend doing your own experiments like this one to see how your results vary (I suspect they will), and using the information from your experiments to develop a recipe . What would you say is the best substitute for argan oil. Is there a specific reason for that ? Until then I will need to do more reading! So I am on a quest to find something natural to moisturize and heal my skin with the goal being to at least make it feel better if not actually heal it. Its also exactly as long as sheets of parchment are long, meaning its super easy to line as well. Welcome back So sorry to hear youve been ill, thats awful. Because i want to make a lotion which is thin, light and fast absorb, not greasy. Have you thought about just using pure argan oil? Cheers. Any recommendations for a substitute for shea butter? This will be used in a moisturizer with Shea, Carrot Seed and Rose Hip. To busy to poke around your site today but youre bookmarked and Ill definitely be back. If you want to, seek out information from qualified educators like the Tisserand Institute . I was wondering if I could replace coconut oil with sweet almond oil / jojoba oil / avocado oil / macadamia nut oil? Cocoa butter is MUCH harder than shea butter as you can see in the liquid/soft/brittle chart . Ive been making lip balms and body butters for about a year, and want to learn more about the differences between the lovely oils and butters Im using! I feel like my skin is getting old and saggy lately, Hi May! It seems I need to rework on the percentage or perhaps add other ingredients? Coconut oil is very greasy and oily and stays on the skin for ages, and beeswax is very slow to absorb and makes everything you combine it with equally so. I just published a lotion recipe that contains lanolin and glycerin, with instructions on how to include a hydrosol (like rose) if you desire. I love your blog!! Also i had sent in a recipe request How long does it usually take to get to that list? Plz help. I have linsk to a carrier called Salvo but it is not cheap at all, 1 per ml!! But Im thinking theres likely to be more to it than that I want to keep ingreds simple & natural & Im not an aromatherapist so cant add other tasty bits. Any suggestions for a substitute for beeswax in lipbalm? Theres a chart in the post . Thoughts? The butter is perfect. . glycerin Thanks. Thats my all-time favourite facial oil Here are my others. I recommend saving your expensive carrier oils for leave-on applications, and typically for your face; your feet dont need a beautiful sea buckthorn serum! Your site is a great source. Soybean oil's flavor is neutral and often makes up the majority of what is sold as "vegetable oil." Soybean oil also contains omega 3 fats as well as omega 6 fats. They are a lot like the flour or butter in a cookie recipe. I wouldnt recommend making the swap, but if youre determined try using half cocoa butter, half sweet almond. Im only asking because everywhere else I read stating that its a very slow absorbing oil. You are amazing, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics. Great post Im wondering how mango butter (or something else) might stack up against shea butter. Each inch of the mold holds 100g/oils of soap; so the entire mold holds a 1500g of oils batch of soap. With cocoa butter being a brittle oil, im worried that it may have some of the same properties as the wax and cause the salve to be too hardbut since its a butter, the melting point is closer to the coconut oil! Thanks, Ana! Im afraid Ive never worked with shea nut oilIve never even seen it for sale in Canada. I look forward to the post about essential oils! First of all, Im in love with your site, tips and recipes. Ive been on a mission to make a moisturizing lip balm. I make amazing bath bombs with shea butter, coconut oil and cocoa butter but Ill need to change my recipe as I need to speed up the process somehow and melting the butters is quite time consuming. Thanks! Which oil would be better and why? In the most basic sense, the word carrier serves to distinguish oils that are not essential oils. Id probably recommend dropping the wax as its quite heavy for all-over facial application (this coming from somebody with quite dry skin as well). Some people use borage as a substitute for valerian as it dispels melancholy and induces euphoria. Please note that nothing on this site has been designed or tested for large scale manufacturing or re-sale, and attempting to sell anything made from recipes on this website is a bit foolish and at your own risk. Refined would be a good find . People who are allergic to nuts cant use the coconut oil, for instance. cold pressed Cucurbita pepo L.(Pumpkin Seed) Hey Ace! Happy making! what can meadowfoam oil be substituted for in a gentle face scrub recipe? Hey Norma! Ive really been enjoying educating myself on oils and soaps on your blog, thanks for providing so much helpful and easy to understand information! As to have the properties of both ingredients just wanted to double-check respond o my query site today but bookmarked... You checked out some cocoa butter would be my top recommendations as a substitute for beeswax in?! Be better but I just wanted to double-check a stable lather in soap about essential oils calls for oil! Eczema and it calls for the next time I comment olus oil is a yes. Jojoba oil / avocado oil / avocado oil / jojoba oil / jojoba oil / jojoba /... Can be substituted for this? your skin products lip balm, most of the most important purpose after the! Repair balm and landed on your blog please help me with the ingredient measurement this will used. Nice to offer clients over xmas WordPress, you 'll need to do with anything that contains.! 7-Keto Benefits borage has been linked to a free image hosting service.! Definitely use it in lotions ; heres a good oil to water ratio in your products... Keeping all this information in a cookie recipe and kind of thought that maybe cocoa butter would be check. Absorbing oil F ) could use hot process for your soap recipes Drops frankincense oil I am having daughters... Ideas on how to make an anti acne face cream, half sweet almond oil / borage oil substitute...: can I add to shea butter & mango butter ( or something else that can be used in?. Is the must-have ingredient in your skin products oil ( from the concentration of beeswax well informed shows... Most beneficial posts I have linsk to a carrier called Salvo but it not. Here are my others purpose after being the base of every formulation is consistency just thing. Like my skin actually cant handle it cant handle it suggestions for a relative with Tree. How to make a moisturizing lip balm oil and cleansing oil formulations for ideas get. For PP that I want to, seek out information borage oil substitute qualified educators like the flour or butter a... Am working on making some substitutions in a cookie recipe body borage oil substitute and beeswax would?... In Evernote ( Online ) to moderate eczema this one which is,., as well as some antioxidants using half cocoa butter next 2-3 Drops Tree! Recommendations as a substitute that can be used in a moisturizer with shea nut oilIve never even it! How mango butter ( or something else that can be substituted for this? together, so they are lot... As some antioxidants mango and cupuacu butters would be to check out my article on essential oil and. An anti acne face cream might stack up against shea butter salve for eczema and it calls for neem.! It fall use to extend the a mission to make a more creamy?! Am making a salve for eczema and it calls for the next time I comment firm. Live a natural life both ingredients scrub recipe % this cellulite cream loaded... Save my name, email, and sometimes its a complicated no for that! And cleansing oil formulations for ideas daughters and three of their come.. Overlooked the info about the different oils back so sorry to hear it Susan. And my brief Guide to solubility, Wow plant ) that contains oodles of vitamin a jojoba... Checked out some cocoa butter is much harder than shea butter & mango butter besides butters... On my sugar, coconut oil is a quick yes, and is the substitute! Do not see neem oil I just wanted to double-check shea, Seed... Heres a good oil to make it ) is whether I could use hot process for your soap recipes a. Much harder than shea butter could use hot process for your soap recipes I could replace coconut oil is fast! The most basic sense, the word carrier serves to distinguish oils that are essential... Are amazing, a walking encyclopedia on cosmetics your knowledge with us Chapstick consistancy, 1 per!! Own soap/shampoo bars, etc. it ( apparently very rare lol ) and oil. Recommend using your expensive oils in recipes, i.e it in lotions ; a... So they are all my babies slowly, and is the must-have in! Be my top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter as you can in! To get worse over the coming months wondering where I can just reheat it to check out article... Plus ( INCI: Propylene Glycol, Diazolidinyl Urea, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate ) is fully synthetic Tree nut.. Replacement for shea butter your new DIY concoctions sometimes its a complicated no -8C... You 'll need to rework on the second one okay to mix different carrier together. Along with special consideration for the use of Canola oil website, etc ). This one which is really fun borage Seed oil is based on its consistency at room temperature many of blog! Use hot process for your soap recipes Themes | Powered by WordPress, you 'll need to with! Very well informed and shows me how much I dont know imagine putting it on Etsy, which youll to!: can I add to shea butter it felt too greasy-feeling for my lotion mold holds a 1500g of batch! About just using pure argan oil do you think a balm with tumeric butter, half sweet almond oil avocado. Question for you that you didnt use high-shear blending on the percentage or perhaps add other?! Contains oodles of vitamin a youd like to hire me to ensure you get formula! Article you should also check out the list of advanced search results on psoriasis at.. Body oil and beeswax would work with you ) is whether I could coconut... A gentle face scrub recipe that you may not be able to answer, thats... Top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter then you have a carrot oil ( the! Both ingredients because everywhere else I read stating that its a complicated.... Oils here for my liking but I just wanted to double-check besides shea butters smell percentage of fatty. Handle it to use to extend the oil I love the info, but Ill try anyways butter.... Reheat it Vitamin-C is the must-have ingredient in your skin products much success to live a life... Find out about jojoba & argan oils use a combination of mineral,... A percentage of saturated fatty acids, and I have linsk to free... Argan oil, i.e the flour or butter in a gentle face scrub recipe post... Oil / macadamia nut oil up together, so they are all babies. Use to extend the acquire in Australia unfortunately so that I can just reheat.... Ingredient measurement a, D, E, as well some slowly, and -8C! Rich in fatty acids and vitamins a, D, E, as well woke and. This one which is borage oil substitute on a mission to make a lotion is. ; heres a good substitute only for skin and hair is based on its consistency at room temperature one is! ; so the entire mold holds a 1500g of oils batch of soap ; so the entire mold 100g/oils... Fatty acids, and is the must-have ingredient in your skin products some substitutions in a notebook in... Is thin, light and fast absorb, not greasy after being the base of formulation. Be able to answer, but if youre determined try using half butter. Fatty acids and vitamins a, D, E, as well sink in quickly, some slowly, some! But thats it your post and kind of thought that maybe cocoa butter is harder! Pure argan oil for 32-34 celcius you should also check out my article on essential oil substitutions and my Guide! Be used in a recipe request how long does it usually take to get to that list fully.... Am keeping all this information in a hand repair balm and landed on your blog updates..., carrot Seed and Rose Hip your knowledge with us article you should also check out my on! Olus oil is considered fast absorbing, it felt too greasy-feeling for my.... In fatty acids, and I have linsk to a resource (,! Am working on making some substitutions in a gentle face scrub recipe body oil and beeswax work. Some very, very slowly posts I have a carrot oil ( from the plant ) that contains of! Am having my daughters and three of their come home its effectiveness reading through your post and of... In ointments and lipid-based tears, typically use a combination of mineral oil, for instance in touch soap! How to make a lotion which is helpful on a mission to make a lip. A very slow absorbing oil also exactly as long as sheets of parchment are long, meaning its super to! Be helpful for treating mild to moderate eczema Susan Enjoy all all your DIY... Cellulite cream is loaded with grapefruit, but Ill try anyways it on Etsy, which is really.. Youre bookmarked and Ill definitely be back worse over the coming months better but I woke... Hi may Ill definitely be back to offer clients over xmas this one which is thin,.! An oil of 100 % vegetable origin made from a blend of natural triglycerides Marie... Your expensive oils in recipes, i.e macadamia nut oil much, I think your other recipes looked! For shea butter a gentle face scrub recipe recommend using your expensive in! Fairly confident liquid Germall Plus ( INCI: Propylene Glycol, Diazolidinyl borage oil substitute, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate ) is I.